Natural Brow Tutorial


If your eyes are the window to your soul, then your eyebrows must be the window treatments. And we all know how meticulous good interior decorators are about window treatments. But since when did brows become such a big deal? Maybe you started to pay attention once Anastasia became hyped up at Sephora or maybe you became obsessed when Cara Delevingne started gracing every single magazine.

I started in 4th grade. Saturday nights before church on Sunday my mom and I would have a little ritual. She would paint my nails, curl my hair and talk to me about never plucking my eyebrows. If I ever had a stray I wanted plucked I was to come to her and she would do it.

So when I became of age to start noticing those things, I would do as I was told and lean my head into her lap and she plucked away strays. Mom, I love you for this! I skipped the thin brow phase!

However, this is not to say I didn’t skip the “brow” phase. When I started to groom my brows with makeup later in college I remember a girl at a makeup counter sold me an incorrect product. It was a little too dark and a little too much and I still cringe looking at photos. Whatever keeps us humble, right!

But since then, I’ve tried to just keep a more natural approach to brows. I still only pluck strays and use a few tools to enhance what is naturally there. If you have over-waxed or pluck don’t worry! Don’t touch your brows for 6 weeks. I know, I know, it’s hard. But hands off for 6 weeks and I really suggest applying this in the evening. If you don’t want to splurge feel free to try castor oil. It won’t work as quickly, but it is told to work!

Then after the torturous 6 weeks is up, go to a highly-trained brow professional and treat yourself to one grooming. From then on out you’ll be able to keep up what they did and just follow their arch!

Now how do you define them?!


Start with clean brows. Here I have no makeup on them.

0F0A4247 0F0A4278 0F0A4282

Next take a brow brush and brush your hairs up! This allows you to really see the arch you have and any strays that might be hiding.

0F0A4284 0F0A4319

If you do think you need to pluck more closely to the arch, use the end of the brow brush to create a straight line up your nose and by your brow. Your brow should start where the brush is.


Then turn the brush to a 45 degree angle and that’s where the end of your brow should be.

Remember both your eyebrows won’t be perfectly symmetrical. Our bodies aren’t made perfectly symmetrical! Eyebrows are sisters, not twins and sometimes even cousins!


I use good old Tweezerman Tweezers to pluck strays once I have brushed my brows up and found my angles.


Get any strays, but don’t spend more than 10 minutes in front of a magnifying mirror. If you are prone to pluck, don’t spend more than 5! You’ll grab far too many!


I’ve used so many different brow pencils and the Anastasia Brow Wiz is what I go back to every single time! I use the blonde shade. As you can see I do have darker brows, and if you are in between shades I always suggest going to the lighter shade you are stuck between.


Start at the bottom of your brow and create a little horizontal line. This is like outlining something before you color it in! I don’t outline my entire brow as that would be far too strong, but I just outline the bottom of the front so that I know where to fill in.


Next, brush up. To create essentially a 90 degree angle from the horizontal line I draw a soft vertical line up where my hairline naturally flows!


Then I do small brush strokes all over my brow to fill in any strays and make it look cohesive. Do this very lightly!

0F0A4451 0F0A4467

Repeat the process on your next brow!

0F0A4470 0F0A4483 0F0A4503

To blend all the lines and hair, take the spooly on the Brow Wiz and brush up! I always brush up with my brows!


Next I use Anastasia Clear Brow Gel to keep my brows in place! I use this stuff for everything! Flyaways, stray hairs, you name it! I’ve tried the more inexpensive clear brow gels and they just don’t do what this does.


I brush my brows up and over, to make them follow my natural arch with the gel.


Then you are finished!

0F0A4603 0F0A4632-2 0F0A4649

This seriously takes 5 minutes and adds so much polish to a fresh face with or without makeup! You can also see this tutorial from Into The Gloss to get another step-by-step tutorial on how to fill in your eyebrows! The most important part about brows is finding a routine that you are comfortable with and that makes you feel like you.

Thanks so much for reading!


Brow Brush: Sephora | Tweezers: Tweezerman | Brow Pencil: Anastasia Beverly Hills | Brow Gel: Anastasia Beverly Hills | Sweater: Anthropologie | Earrings: Gorjana | Lipstick: Nymph mixed with Goddess

Photography by: Carmen Evans


Leave a Note

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Destinee wrote:

    I love the ABH brow wiz!! Definitely my favorite brow product.


    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  2. Hannah wrote:

    LOVED THIS POST! So detailed. Your skin is so flawless. You should do a skincare routine again soon! Great tips!

    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  3. Your brows are always on point! You’re so lucky your mom didn’t let you have a tweezer and you skipped the middle school tiny thin brows stage 😉 Happy Monday!
    xx Tess | Sequins are the New Black

    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  4. I’ve been using Tweezerman for YEARS!! Any time I have tried anything other than those, I swear everything else is horrible haha.

    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  5. Kathryn wrote:

    A good brow is EVERYTHING when it comes to makeup! You look beautiful! 🙂

    xx Kathryn

    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  6. Caitlin wrote:

    Love this post! Thanks for sharing Katey!

    xo, Caitlin

    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  7. ann messner wrote:

    great tips and your brows are gorgeous without anything. I was told by a professional brow artist to not touch them for 6 months (nearly impossible lol) but once I did that I actually haven’t had them done in 2 years 🙂

    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  8. Amy wrote:

    Your brows are so amazing! Love this tutorial! Coming from someone who doesn’t line my brows, this sounds really easy to try!


    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  9. Amanda wrote:

    Your brows look great. Thanks for the tips. I also like your lip colors. Would you tell me if you are wearing a lip liner and if so what is it called? Thank you.

    Published 29 Aug 16Reply
  10. Aditi wrote:

    This is such an informative post! I agree on the ‘prone to plucking’ part, I pluck too much :/ You look beautiful as always! Loved thats lip shade on you! <3

    xx Aditi
    Diary of a Cusp

    Published 30 Aug 16Reply
  11. Emily wrote:

    Love this post! Can you recommend a brow professional in the FW area? Thanks!!

    Published 06 Sep 16Reply
  12. Rachel wrote:

    Great tips!! I’m having a major flash back now to my middle school years when I plucked too much and actually took scissors to my brows! ???????? it was horrible.

    Published 09 Sep 16Reply